
Energiedoden
Energy doesn’t only cost money, it also costs human lives. Scientific American published an article in their September issue about how many human lives are lost when generating a given amount of electricity.
In the image on the right (apologies for the low quality, I took a photo with my mobile phone) clearly shows that the ‘fossil three’, coal, petroleum and natural gas, cause the most deaths by far. The graph shows the number of deaths per 100 GigaWatt, generated for year. Coal takes 12 lives per 100 GWyear, especially during exploration and extraction.
Petroleum and natural gas are less lethal with 9,4 and 7,2 respectively, but still many more people are killed using these forms of energy when compared with more sustainable alternatives. Most death occur in the transport and local distribution phases.
Nuclear power performs much better with only 0,73, but the deaths as a result of the nuclear disasters in Chernobyl and Fukushima have not been counted in that number (the article doesn’t state why). I have not way to estimate how much higher this number would be when the number of direct and indirect deaths caused by the Chernobyl and Fukushima disasters would have been counted.
Hydroelectricity is, when calculated in human lives lost, more than a factor two safer than nuclear power with 0,27 deaths per 100 GWyear, while onshore wind and geothermal are a bit safer still with0,19and 0,17 deaths per 100 GWyear respectively
But the absolute star of this graph is photovoltaics (the technology behind solar panels like we have on our roof) with only 0,02 deaths per 100 GWyear. That’s sixty times less than coal power and thirty-seven times less than nuclear power.
It’s very likely that especially the number of deaths in the exploration and extraction phase are in reality even higher because this article only used data from OECD member states. These are all western, well-developed countries where employees in the energy sector are well-protected and which have relatively strict environmental laws. I also can’t tell if deaths caused by the effects of climate change have been counted in the numbers used in this graph.
This article shows that besides being safe and cheap solar power is also very safe. Yet another reason to install solar panels as soon as possible!